Retrospective: Alan Wake Xbox 360 Review

Alan Wake

I’m a long time fan of Remedy Entertainment from way back, when all they did was code tech demos for PC benchmarking. Their break-out 2001 game, Max Payne, successfully melded an adult, hard-boiled storyline with explosive gameplay and graphics. A couple of years later Max Payne 2 took it all to the next level. With Alan Wake, Remedy took the know-how from Max Payne and applied to something more akin to an episode of The Twilight Zone.

When I first heard about Alan Wake it was via a tiny piece in the front pages of a UK games mag, it was a bit different to the game that Microsoft ended up publishing in 2010. The early Alan Wake was a sandbox game where Alan could wander around Bright Falls safely during daylight, but was pursued by evil during the night. For reasons that are beyond me now, I was quite taken with the idea of taking a cable car up into the mountains. I think it was the whole newness od the interactive sandbox thing. I still enjoy aimlessly wandering and exploring in games like Far Cry 2 and Fallout 3. I wonder what that sandbox Bright Falls would have played like, especially as I’m currently having so much fun with the zombie sandbox, Dead Island. Remedy have gone on record stating that the changes were necessary to tighten and refine the story experience, something that they believed to be impossible with a sandbox environment.

I never thought that the game got the commercial recognition that it deserved. It didn’t help that it was released on the dame day as Red Dead Redemption; a game which I’ll admit to being a far, far more superior than Alan Wake. You can easily find a new copy of Alan Wake for a sub-$50 price and at that price it’s well worth a punt. Below you’ll find my review of Alan Wakeas previously published in the June 2010 issue of the New Zealand Game Console print magazine. Enjoy.

Alan Wake
Look at those wonderful trees


Five years is a long time to wait for a video-game; but that’s how long it’s been since Remedy Entertainment first announced the follow-up to their Max Payne series, Alan Wake. Moving on from Max Payne’s hard-boiled pulp noir, this time Remedy has drawn upon the likes of Stephen King, Twin Peaks, The X-Files and Lost to create a creepy horror tale that exploits our primal fear of darkness.

The game starts as troubled novelist, Alan Wake and his wife Alice arrive in the sleepy American northwest town of Bright Falls. Alice hopes that the seclusion will free her husband from his torment and help him to get over his writers block. There is a Dark Presence lurking in Caldron Lake that has other plans for them both.

You are quickly drawn into a roller-coaster ride in which Alan Wake must save the woman he loves in an epic battle of light verses darkness. The Taken, hunters possessed by the Dark Presence, haunt the town and surrounding forests by night. They lurk in the shadows usually with bloodied axe in hand, hell-bent on stopping Alan from being reunited with his wife. Alan Wake’s story is well told, in a similar narrated style to Max Payne, which is hardly surprising considering they share the same author. My only complaint would be that by episode four, the game has pretty much put all its cards on the table.

Alan Wake
Coming through

During development Remedy ditched their initial open-world aspirations for the game; the result is a tight and focused action adventure game, the likes of which would be very difficult to achieve with a open-world sandbox. That being said, the game doesn’t feel overly scripted, nor does it play like it’s on rails and the environments are still big enough to get lost in. I think it was a good design choice and the game is much better for it. This extra control has also allowed the developers to better pace the game using the day/night cycle.

The daytime sequences allow you catch your breath and interact with the townsfolk and drive the story. After dark things get a little more sinister. The fight with light combat system works very well. Weapons alone have no effect in the game. Whilst shining your torch at The Taken will keep them at bay, you must boost the beam to burn away the darkness that protects them. Boosting uses up batteries, which you can replace if you have any, if not, you must wait for them to recharge.  Without the darkness The Taken are vulnerable to bullets. It is easy to get overrun as you change batteries and reload you guns. Thankfully, flash-bangs and flare guns will instantly send The Taken to the hereafter.

Throughout Bright Falls you will find weapons and ammo caches sign-posted in light-sensitive paint; it seems that Alan Wake has an unseen ally in the town. The same Good Samaritan has also marked the way to the game’s brightly lit safe havens, usually streetlights that also serve as game checkpoints.

Alan Wake
Welcome to Bright Falls

Scattered around the level are manuscript pages from a novel that Alan doesn’t remember writing.  This novel is the story that you are playing. Finding and reading the pages will reveal additional information about “off screen” events and some times even tell you what is going to happen next.

There are three difficulty settings, Normal, Hard and Nightmare. On Normal, playing at a leisurely pace, the game should take you a good 15-16 hours to complete.  As well as the manuscript pages, there are plenty of other secrets to find. Collecting the secrets and completing the game on the harder difficulty modes gives the game some good replay value.

There are references and sly winks for fans of the horror/mystery genre peppered throughout the game. The biggest nod to the game’s inspiration is the way that the game plays out as if it was a six episode TV series. Each episode even starts with a “Previously on Alan Wake” recap, which is a nice touch.

Alan Wake
Fight with light

The visuals are very detailed and atmospheric. The wind effect in the woods, with the light dancing between the swaying branches, is particularly impressive. The graphics occasionally appear a little more jagged and pixelated than I’d like, especially the background environmental effects. That being said, there is often a lot going on and yet the game always maintains a very decent frame rate.  The presentation quality of the pre-rendered cut scenes is a bit disappointing, ranging from nasty-looking to passable. The videos suffer from compression artefacts that I thought we had seen the last of a decade ago. Even the best sequences are dark and muddy when compared to the palette of the  in-game graphics engine. But don’t let any of this put you off; overall the graphics are quite good and these little niggles do very little to detract from the game experience.

The soundtrack is great, and can be directly access via the extras menu as you progress through the game and unlock the tracks. Alan Wake features licensed songs by Roy Orbison, Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds,  Bowie and many others. There are also a couple of awesome tracks credited to the in-game band, The Old Gods of Asgard.

The riveting plot and perfectly paced action makes Alan Wake a piece of gaming genius. Rather than go for the gross-out horror style of Silent Hill or Resident Evil, Alan Wake is more of a psychological horror story, one that will continue to unnerve you long after you have switched off the game. The graphics, especially the cut scenes could have been better, but with an experience as rare and exquisite as this, one really shouldn’t get hung up on minor grumbles. The game ends with a TV season finale-style cliff-hanger that I’ll have you gagging for more. If the final message at the end of the credit crawl is to be believed “Alan Wake’s journey through the night will continue” and I can’t wait!

Graphics: 8

Sound: 9

Gameplay: 10

Lasting appeal: 8

Overall: 9

A version of this article originally appeared in the June 2010 issue of the New Zealand Game Console print magazine.